Our Team

As your trusted advisor for insurance solutions. We take a careful approach to finding policies that properly cover your home, family and business while providing neighborly, expert advice.
Our insurance agents are located in nine northwest Ohio cities: Archbold, Bowling Green, Bryan, Defiance, Findlay, Fostoria, Lima, Sylvania, and Tiffin.

Andy Weisgerber

Risk Advisor
Andy Weisgerber
Phone: 419-785-2228

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Colin Walton

Personal Lines Risk Advisor
Colin Walton
Phone: 419-720-6508

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Ethan Plummer

Personal Lines Risk Advisor
Ethan Plummer
Phone: 419-785-2222

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Matt Karaffa

Risk Advisor
Matt Karaffa
Phone: 419-354-2749

414 East Wooster St 

Bowling Green, OH 43402

Randy Huber

Personal Lines Advisor
Randy Huber
Phone: 419-354-2730

414 East Wooster St 

Bowling Green, OH 43402

Larry Woods

EVP, Risk Advisor
Larry Woods
Phone: 419-785-2225

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Tim Whetstone

Risk Advisor
Tim Whetstone
Phone: 419-785-2224

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Trey Walker

Select Business Risk Advisor
Trey Walker
Phone: 419-419-6294

414 East Wooster St 

Bowling Green, OH 43402

John Payak III

EVP, Risk Advisor
John Payak III
Phone: 419-794-7800

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Justin Kruse

Risk Advisor
Justin Kruse
Phone: 419-318-0278

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Marty Dubbs

EVP, Risk Advisor
Marty Dubbs
Phone: 419-720-6500

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Mike Denman

Risk Advisor
Mike Denman
Phone: 567-455-8247

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Robert Truckor

Risk Advisor
Robert Truckor
Phone: 419-784-5011

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Deb Bechstein

Account Manager
Deb Bechstein
Phone: 419-354-2737
414 East Wooster St

Tanya Kerecz

Account Manager
Tanya Kerecz
Phone: 419-354-2733
414 East Wooster St

Darby Naton

Account Manager
Darby Naton
Phone: 419-785-2235
511 Fifth Street

Hayley Leatherman

Account Manager
Hayley Leatherman
Phone: 419-785-8552
511 Fifth Street

Kelly Burnett

Account Manager
Kelly Burnett
Phone: 419-785-2203
511 Fifth Street

Regina Bidlack

Account Manager
Regina Bidlack
Phone: 419-785-2243
511 Fifth Street

Susan Friedricksen

Commercial Lines Team Lead
Susan Friedricksen
Phone: 419-785-2244
511 Fifth Street

Janet Sharpe

Account Manager
Janet Sharpe
Phone: 567-455-8245
5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Kim Cullen

Account Manager
Kim Cullen
Phone: 419-720-6507
5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Molly Hale

Commercial Lines Team Lead
Molly Hale
Phone: 419-794-7815
5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Renae VanBrackel

Account Manager
Renae VanBrackel
Phone: 419-794-5022
5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Andy Weisgerber

Risk Advisor
Andy Weisgerber
Phone: 419-785-2228

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Colin Walton

Personal Lines Risk Advisor
Colin Walton
Phone: 419-720-6508

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Ethan Plummer

Personal Lines Risk Advisor
Ethan Plummer
Phone: 419-785-2222

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Matt Karaffa

Risk Advisor
Matt Karaffa
Phone: 419-354-2749

414 East Wooster St 

Bowling Green, OH 43402

Randy Huber

Personal Lines Advisor
Randy Huber
Phone: 419-354-2730

414 East Wooster St 

Bowling Green, OH 43402

Larry Woods

EVP, Risk Advisor
Larry Woods
Phone: 419-785-2225

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Tim Whetstone

Risk Advisor
Tim Whetstone
Phone: 419-785-2224

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Trey Walker

Select Business Risk Advisor
Trey Walker
Phone: 419-419-6294

414 East Wooster St 

Bowling Green, OH 43402

John Payak III

EVP, Risk Advisor
John Payak III
Phone: 419-794-7800

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Justin Kruse

Risk Advisor
Justin Kruse
Phone: 419-318-0278

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Marty Dubbs

EVP, Risk Advisor
Marty Dubbs
Phone: 419-720-6500

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Mike Denman

Risk Advisor
Mike Denman
Phone: 567-455-8247

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Robert Truckor

Risk Advisor
Robert Truckor
Phone: 419-784-5011

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Amy Biegel

Account Manager
Amy Biegel
Phone: 419-354-2758
414 East Wooster St

Joan Bonnough

Account Manager
Joan Bonnough
Phone: 419-354-2740
414 East Wooster St

Heidi Walters

Account Manager
Heidi Walters
Phone: 419-785-2243
511 Fifth Street

Jill Kretz

Account Manager
Jill Kretz
Phone: 419-785-2226
511 Fifth Street

Karen Dickerson

Claims
Karen Dickerson
Phone: 419-785-2208
511 Fifth Street

Nancy Kiessling

Personal Lines Team Lead
Nancy Kiessling
Phone: 419-785-2236
511 Fifth Street

Pat Hire

Account Manager
Pat Hire
Phone: 419-785-2214
511 Fifth Street

Amy Allen

Account Manager
Amy Allen
Phone: 419-720-6504
5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Heather Gaisie

Account Manager
Heather Gaisie
Phone: 419-720-6511
5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Laurie Knitz

Personal Lines Team Lead-Claims Specialist
Laurie Knitz
Phone: 419-720-6502
5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Rita Monroe

Account Manager
Rita Monroe
Phone: 419-794-7810
5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Wendy Radwanski

Account Manager
Wendy Radwanski
Phone: 419-794-7808
5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Ben Otley

Employee Benefits Consultant
Ben Otley
Phone: 419-354-2734

414 East Wooster St 

Bowling Green, OH 43402

Mike Kurivial

Employee Benefits Consultant
Mike Kurivial
Phone: 419-633-0823

204 East High Street

Bryan, OH 43506

Ken Keller

Employee Benefits Consultant
Ken Keller
Phone: 419-785-2212

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Julie Pantello

Employee Benefits Consultant
Julie Pantello
Phone: 419-741-7466

2600 Allentown Rd. 

Lima, OH 45805

Amanda Brown

Employee Benefits Consultant
Amanda Brown
Phone: 419-794-7811

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Zak Weimer

Employee Benefits Consultant
Zak Weimer
Phone: 419-436-7627

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Kim Bond

Employee Benefits Consultant
Kim Bond
Phone: 419-436-7628

1650 N Countyline St, Suite 200 

Fostoria, OH 44830

Ron Burns

EVP, Employee Benefits Consultant
Ron Burns
Phone: 419-436-7626

1650 N Countyline St, Suite 200 

Fostoria, OH 44830

Karla Ball

Employee Benefits Consultant
Karla Ball
Phone: 419-445-0125

107 Ditto Street, Suite 400

Archbold, OH 43502

Tiffany Pease

Individual and Senior Sales Consultant
Tiffany Pease
Phone: 419-785-2227

511 Fifth Street
Defiance, OH 43512

Lisa Tipping

Account Manager
Lisa Tipping
Phone: 419-354-2736
414 East Wooster St

Lana Ellison

Account Manager
Lana Ellison
Phone: 419-633-0668
204 East High St.

Julie Keller

Account Manager
Julie Keller
Phone: 419-785-2213
511 Fifth Street

Misty Dunson

Customer Service Representative
Misty Dunson
Phone: 419-785-2247
511 Fifth Street

Cassandra Saldusky

Benefits Marketing Specialist
Cassandra Saldusky
Phone: 419-436-7636
1650 N Countyline St, Suite 200

Diana Bushman

Account Manager
Diana Bushman
Phone: 567-245-4912
1650 N Countyline St, Suite 200

Jaclyn Arbogast

Account Manager
Jaclyn Arbogast
Phone: 419-427-0622
1650 N Countyline St, Suite 200

Jacob Dryfuse

Benefit Analyst
Jacob Dryfuse
Phone: 419-436-7638
1650 N Countyline St, Suite 200

Jill Schalk

Account Manager
Jill Schalk
Phone: 419-436-7635
1650 N Countyline St, Suite 200

Joanne Herrig

Account Manager
Joanne Herrig
Phone: 419-436-7630
1650 N Countyline St, Suite 200

Laura Sheets

Benefit Analyst
Laura Sheets
Phone: 419-436-7637
1650 N Countyline St, Suite 200

Lori Hall

Director of HR Services
Lori Hall
Phone: 419-436-7629
1650 N Countyline St, Suite 200

Andrea Peters

Account Manager
Andrea Peters
Phone: 419-741-7465
2600 Allentown Road

Cathy Collins

Account Manager
Cathy Collins
Phone: 419-741-7464
2600 Allentown Road

Brendan Squillante

Benefits Marketing Specialist
Brendan Squillante
Phone: 419-318-0276
5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Jennifer Waldvogel

Account Manager
Jennifer Waldvogel
Phone: 419-794-7803
5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Lori Huth

Account Manager
Lori Huth
Phone: 419-436-7632
643 Miami Street, Suite 5

Julie Guth

Customer Service Representative
Julie Guth
Phone: 419-436-7633
643 Miami Street, Suite 5

Nikki Hills

Customer Service Representative
Nikki Hills
Phone: 419-443-8287
643 Miami Street, Suite 5

Daniel Crews

Benefits Marketing Specialist
Daniel Crews
Phone: 567-455-8243
5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Nick Mehdikhan

President & COO
Nick Mehdikhan

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Luke Shipp

P&C Practice Leader
Luke Shipp
Phone: 419-794-7816

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Chad Ritter

Technology Coordinator
Chad Ritter
Phone: 419-785-2234

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Ellen Bechstein

System Administrator
Ellen Bechstein
Phone: 419-354-2742

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Kim Moore

Administrative Assistant
Kim Moore
Phone: 416-784-5431

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Barb Gerken

Director of Employee Benefits Compliance
Barb Gerken
Phone: 419-794-7802

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Jessica Vietmeier

Marketing Coordinator
Jessica Vietmeier
Phone: 419-783-3073

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Kaylyn Huber

Administrative Assistant
Kaylyn Huber
Phone: 419-784-5431

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Melissa Sayers

Business Resource Coordinator
Melissa Sayers
Phone: 419-794-7804

5520 Monroe St. Suite A

Sylvania, OH 43560

Nancy Rensi

Accounting
Nancy Rensi
Phone: 419-782-3988

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Kristi Schaufele

Accounting
Kristi Schaufele
Phone: 419-785-3740

511 Fifth Street

Defiance, OH 43512

Jillian Conley

Administrative Assistant
Jillian Conley
Phone: 419-436-4085

1650 N Countyline St, Suite 200 

Fostoria, OH 44830

Nick Mehdikhan

President & COO

Luke Shipp

P&C Practice Leader
Luke Shipp
Phone: 419-794-7816

Andy Weisgerber

Risk Advisor
Andy Weisgerber
Phone: 419-785-2228

Ben Otley

Employee Benefits Consultant
Ben Otley
Phone: 419-354-2734

Colin Walton

Personal Lines Risk Advisor
Colin Walton
Phone: 419-720-6508

Ethan Plummer

Personal Lines Risk Advisor
Ethan Plummer
Phone: 419-785-2222

Matt Karaffa

Risk Advisor
Matt Karaffa
Phone: 419-354-2749

Mike Kurivial

Employee Benefits Consultant
Mike Kurivial
Phone: 419-633-0823

Randy Huber

Personal Lines Advisor
Randy Huber
Phone: 419-354-2730

Chad Ritter

Technology Coordinator
Chad Ritter
Phone: 419-785-2234

Ellen Bechstein

System Administrator
Ellen Bechstein
Phone: 419-354-2742

Ken Keller

Employee Benefits Consultant
Ken Keller
Phone: 419-785-2212

Kim Moore

Administrative Assistant
Kim Moore
Phone: 416-784-5431

Larry Woods

EVP, Risk Advisor
Larry Woods
Phone: 419-785-2225

Tim Whetstone

Risk Advisor
Tim Whetstone
Phone: 419-785-2224

Trey Walker

Select Business Risk Advisor
Trey Walker
Phone: 419-419-6294

Julie Pantello

Employee Benefits Consultant
Julie Pantello
Phone: 419-741-7466

Amanda Brown

Employee Benefits Consultant
Amanda Brown
Phone: 419-794-7811

Barb Gerken

Director of Employee Benefits Compliance
Barb Gerken
Phone: 419-794-7802

Jessica Vietmeier

Marketing Coordinator
Jessica Vietmeier
Phone: 419-783-3073

John Payak III

EVP, Risk Advisor
John Payak III
Phone: 419-794-7800

Justin Kruse

Risk Advisor
Justin Kruse
Phone: 419-318-0278

Kaylyn Huber

Administrative Assistant
Kaylyn Huber
Phone: 419-784-5431

Marty Dubbs

EVP, Risk Advisor
Marty Dubbs
Phone: 419-720-6500

Melissa Sayers

Business Resource Coordinator
Melissa Sayers
Phone: 419-794-7804

Mike Denman

Risk Advisor
Mike Denman
Phone: 567-455-8247

Robert Truckor

Risk Advisor
Robert Truckor
Phone: 419-784-5011

Zak Weimer

Employee Benefits Consultant
Zak Weimer
Phone: 419-436-7627

Kim Bond

Employee Benefits Consultant
Kim Bond
Phone: 419-436-7628

Ron Burns

EVP, Employee Benefits Consultant
Ron Burns
Phone: 419-436-7626

Karla Ball

Employee Benefits Consultant
Karla Ball
Phone: 419-445-0125

Tiffany Pease

Individual and Senior Sales Consultant
Tiffany Pease
Phone: 419-785-2227

Nancy Rensi

Accounting
Nancy Rensi
Phone: 419-782-3988

Kristi Schaufele

Accounting
Kristi Schaufele
Phone: 419-785-3740

Jillian Conley

Administrative Assistant
Jillian Conley
Phone: 419-436-4085